#809162 - 01/02/07 03:58 AM
Time to take action against Israel?
|
enthusiast
Registered: 04/04/06
Loc: L.O.N.D.O.N.
|
A commons select commitee is pressing for the preferential deal between Israel and the EU to be stopped.
Here is an interesting comment article in the Guardian about it.
Do you back the committee? If so why do you think the EU takes no action?
My view from the ground: icklematt.wordpress.com
|
|
Top
|
|
|
|
#809163 - 01/02/07 08:55 AM
Re: Time to take action against Israel?
[Re: ickleMatt]
|
Carpal \'Tunnel
Registered: 31/12/04
Loc: in the trees
|
i would have read it but i saw it wa from the wooly gaurdian. there is some "slight" truth in news articles, but more often than not they are pollticly biased. take the sun, the daily (biggot) mail, (small minded) news of the world etc. ALL red topped news papers, anti this, anti that but all polliticly motivated. i will however read YOUR link icklemat......................but that will keep till tomorrow 
|
|
Top
|
|
|
|
#809164 - 20/02/07 09:37 AM
Re: Time to take action against Israel?
[Re: alien_oddity]
|
addict
Registered: 25/07/05
Loc: Glasgow
|
Here's the ultimate solution to the Arab-Israeli conflict...
Boot them all out, wall the place up and put all the Scientologists in there.
If they can't play nice, then they shouldn't play at all.
(Apologies for any offence caused) :P
_________________________
Have faith in what you can do and respect for what you can't
|
|
Top
|
|
|
|
#809167 - 21/02/07 03:39 AM
Re: Time to take action against Israel?
[Re: jo_rhymes]
|
Stargazer
Registered: 20/09/03
|
the old debate... IMHO it's time to take action against BOTH sides. IMHO Israel should surrender all arms and open themselves to a massive UN peacekeeping force in their country and Palestinians should be asked to do alike. In this way: where there are no guns, there are no gun related deaths 
_________________________
the best smiles are the ones you lead to
|
|
Top
|
|
|
|
#809170 - 21/02/07 11:23 PM
Re: Time to take action against Israel?
[Re: Sym]
|
Geek-enviro-hippy priest
Registered: 28/09/04
Loc: Diss, Norfolk
|
Written by: Noam Chomsky
There was a free election in Palestine, but it came out the wrong way. So instantly, the United States and Israel with Europe tagging along, moved to punish the Palestinian people, and punish them harshly, because they voted the wrong way in a free election. That's accepted here in the West as perfectly normal. That illustrates the deep hatred and contempt for democracy among western elites, so deep-seated they can't even perceive it when it's in front of their eyes. You punish people severely if they vote the wrong way in a free election. There's a pretext for that too, repeated every day: Hamas must agree to first recognize Israel, second to end all violence, third to accept past agreements. Try to find a mention of the fact that the United States and Israel reject all three of those. They obviously don't recognize Palestine, they certainly don't withdraw the use of violence or the threat of it -- in fact they insist on it -- and they don't accept past agreements, including the road map.
I suspect one of the reasons why Jimmy Carter's book has come under such fierce attack is because it's the first time, I think, in the mainstream, that one can find the truth about the road map. I have never seen anything in the mainstream that discusses the fact that Israel instantly rejected the road map with U.S. support. They formally accepted it but added 14 reservations that totally eviscerated it. It was done instantly. It's public knowledge, I've written about it, talked about it, so have others, but I've never seen it mentioned in the mainstream before. And obviously they don't accept the Arab League proposal or any other serious proposal. In fact they've been blocking the international consensus on the two-state solution for decades. But Hamas has to accept them.
It really makes no sense. Hamas is a political party and political parties don't recognize other countries. And Hamas itself has made it very clear, they actually carried out a truce for a year and a half, didn't respond to Israeli attacks, and have called for a long-term truce, during which it'd be possible to negotiate a settlement along the lines of the international consensus and the Arab League proposal.
All of this is obvious, it's right on the surface, and that's just one example of the deep hatred of democracy on the part of western elites. It's a striking example but you can add case after case. Yet, the president announced the freedom agenda and if the dear leader said something, it's got to be true, kind of North Korean style. Therefore there's a freedom agenda even if there's a mountain of evidence against it, the only evidence for it is in words, even apart from the timing.
More here
_________________________
There's too many home fires burning and not enough trees
|
|
Top
|
|
|
|
#809172 - 22/02/07 01:27 PM
Re: Time to take action against Israel?
[Re: ickleMatt]
|
enthusiast
Registered: 20/05/02
|
I agree with Noam Chomsky on this one point. Refusing to recognize Hamas and withholding aid is disgraceful behaviour. because they're "Terrorists" well it's not like Israeli politicians aren't. Hamas are a democratically government, one of the few in the Arab world. The American position is equivalent to saying you can choose anyone you want so long as it's who we want you to choose. A bit Henry Ford.
The whole area is so frustrating. Every few months theres a suicide bomb attack. The Palestinians say it's revenge for helicopter gunship attacks. the Israelis say that was revenge for previous suicide bomb attacks which in turn were because Israel occupied the Gaza strip.....and so the game of "But he started it" goes on until they're there saying but your forefathers forefathers invaded our forefathers forefathers. Get over it.
Extreme religous ideologies like militant Islam and Zionism are not conducive to compromise or even to what I would consider rational debate. The whole area seems destined to be a mess for the foreseeable future.
I heartily agree though that it's about time Israel felt some international pressure. The occupation, the wall, and the economic destruction of Palestine are very wrong and not even in Israels interests. Not to mention their very significant part in the continued cycle of violence. By the numbers Israel kills far more Palestinians and far more civilians that the intifada ever did.
Edited by Mascot (22/02/07 01:28 PM)
_________________________
Walls may have ears but they don't have eyes
|
|
Top
|
|
|
|
#809175 - 02/03/07 10:02 PM
Re: Time to take action against Israel?
[Re: ickleMatt]
|
enthusiast
Registered: 04/04/06
Loc: L.O.N.D.O.N.
|
We're finished! The circus tour of Israel and Palestine is over. To read my final comments: icklematt.wordpress.com
|
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|